I feel like on this situation you were jumping to conclusions, just because they typed in there caption were basic doesnt mean they were Necessarily talking about the shirt. If, at any time, you have specific questions or concerns about the accessibility of any particular webpage By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. Cultural appropriation has not been handled right, and it needs to stop. Cultural appropriation is while someone makes use of a practice or a culture. Its More Than a Fad Why We Became Vegetarian, Too Young To Have a Say, but Old Enough To Pay, My Mental Health Journey: Harnessing the Power of My Mind. Someone else's culture or raceor an offensive idea of itshould never be a costume or the butt of a joke. the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG), which also bring the Website into conformance with the Americans A Chicana/Chicano is someone who was raised in the United States but also has Mexican origin or a person who was born in Mxico but has a US citizenship. It hasnt happened yet. And it wont. Durags make a statement, but it's more than just fashion. Its a spread of culture to some extent; a celebration of a statement piece that historically stood for something but it has gone through so many social phases that I often wonder if millennials actually take the time to understand its significance., Some style bloggers, such as Abyan Kadir from London, are certainly conscious of the trends deeper meaning. al Aug 25, 2020 at 8:33 pm. . Of course, you can. It's the loose idea of borrowing, sharing and being inspired by other cultures. Cultural appropriation happens every day, especially in the world of fashion. However, bandanas are not just worn by those on the wrong side of the law. Leah Aug 19, 2020 at 11:31 pm. What culture are bandanas? He is the co-author of a paper titled Cultural Appropriation and the Intimacy of Groups. Copyright 2023 Helpful Professor. Additionally,fashion-manufacturing.com participates in various other affiliate programs, and we sometimes get a commission through purchases made through our links. Durags are highly culturally significant to the Black community. I know obviously one subreddit doesn't speak for every POC but I figured it's at least good to ask. Why is it so divisive? 25 Eman Ansari 2 y Of course not! RELATED: The 20 Most Controversial Men's Style Trends of the Past 20 Years, Controversy & Fitch: A History of Abercrombie's Most Flagrant F**k-Ups, The 20 Most Controversial Men's Style Trends of the Past 20 Years. This is when a bandana is often referred to as a headscarf. A deeper understanding of what cultural appropriation is digs up issues of whether it is offensive and even racist. Hi! https://helpfulprofessor.com/author/admin/. It caused quite a stir at the time. Another problem with the video was the caption. Sleeping is another time you should wear your durag, as it will hold your waves in place. The origin of the bandana is unclear, but it is believed to have originated in India or Persia. The aloha shirt has many possible inventors and a long, fraught cultural history. With so many options, theres no wrong way to wear a bandana. Headscarves are known to carry cultural significance for some groups, but generally speaking, bandanas do not. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. Yes, bandanas are the optimum way to keep yourself cool. Generally, whether or not bandanas are rude or disrespectful also usually depends on the surroundings or place youre wearing them. Related Article: Is Henna Cultural Appropriation? It can offend people when people do this without making it clear . While modest fashion bloggers donning durags may receive fame and acclaim on social media, black people are banned from wearing them in many schools, and wearing a durag can be used as a justification for being racially profiled by police, Wheeler points out. Would there be any times where you could wear a banana as an African American person? This was 15 years ago, but the thing is, popular culture has since made me feel like even us genuine Wyoming cholas were never quite 100% authentic. As most of you know by now, there is a trending app that many teens use called TikTok. The style was also worn in the '80s by Guns N' Roses singer Axl Rose, though that is an entirely different story. Cultural appropriation in this sense . Bandanas can mean different things to different people. To avoid issues of cultural appropriation she encourages anyone interested in purchasing waist beads to purchase waist beads from a business that ethically sources their product from an African country or a person of African origin. Well, think again. While the trend may appear aptly timed in light of #BlackLivesMatter, the durag has been on the rise in mainstream fashion: at the spring/summer 2020 New York Fashion Week, American designer Brandon Maxwell styled many of his black models in elegant satin durags, and Rihanna was pictured wearing a black durag on the cover of British Vogue in May. As far as I know, there isn't a marginalized community that wears it in that specific way and I know not to wear it like African women wear their headwraps and stuff like that. At first glance, it appears that this is a harmless act. One stylistic example is the blackletter typeface or Gothic lettering. Like its implications? For instance, Kendall Jenners baby-curled fringe in the new issue of Love. Appropriation is another story. amazing article! This was a great and well written article. If the bandanna is tied to the rollbar, it means you like to catch. A post shared by BIND London (@bindlondon). It does not store any personal data. I have known the bandana print and its surrounding culture through skating and music like US hardcore and West Coasthip-hop. Cultural appropriation is the adoption of certain elements from another culture without the consent of people who belong to that culture. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. Quick question, isnt the bandana originally from India? So, for example,black was for S&M, dark blue was for anal sex, light blue was for oral sex, and so on. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Is it okay to wear bandanas? Bandanas often get worn to keep hair clean and protected when working. In the rest of this article, well explain the vast history of bandanas and why wearing one is not generally seen as cultural appropriation. That is why it is not cultural appropriation to use a bandana for work or fashion purposes. There's are good and bad ways of borrowing culture. Rihanna in chola fancy dress for Halloween in 2013. he Cholas in my Wyoming high school had a very distinct style. The chola look itself is geared around the hair, but extends to the following: dark lipliner with a lighter lipstick, cat-eye glasses, baggy Dickies denim or khakis, oversized flannels buttoned up to the top, gold chains with crucifixes or St Christopher medals dangling at the end and the aforementioned skyscraper bangs. Are Hoop Earrings Cultural Appropriation? Then, tie the bandana around your head, with the point of the triangle at the front. They are a piece of history that has remained intact, allowing the wearer to express who they are. of its Website, www.highsnobiety.com. A recent TikTok displaying it as so is an upsetting example of cultural appropriation. Is it Considered Offensive to wear a Bandana? In July, a video was widely circulated on Instagram. For example, in India, bandanas are commonly worn by members of oppressed communities to resist discrimination. One of the first mass introductions to chola culture was the 1994 film Mi Vida Loca, which followed a clique of five chola gangbangers in Echo Park, Los Angeles. The reality of cultural appropriation is that it is always going to be a debate. But when people mimic the style of marginalised ethnic groups, that's. But when people mimic the style of marginalised ethnic groups, thats not cool, thats cultural appropriation. But nothing can top Sandra Bullock getting a chola makeover on the George Lopez talk show in 2009 (racist, as far as I can tell), or even Selena Gomez dressing in chola style at the MTV awards in 2011. That is because a bandana has no specific cultural roots in anyones culture or heritage. Beyond "does it look good on me" you should maybe consider what it says about you before you dip into the cultural style pool and there are some clothing choices that you're better off avoiding altogether, like these. The bandana was also a common article of clothing long before it became a significant fashion staple for cultures. While debate rightly rages on about whether Katy Perry and Brooke Candy should be sporting cornrows and box braids traditionally black hairstyles that paint them as racial interlopers who may be trying on the ghetto chic look (not my words) and festivals have started banning Native American headdresses from their grounds, pop culture barely blinks an eye when chola style is borrowed, plundered, caricatured and/or cartoonised for the benefit of new ideas and, of course, the same coolness that I was so enamoured of during my teens. Alexa is a junior at La Salle. A white woman can wear a bandana or headscarf without fear that she is participating in cultural appropriation. Pop-cultural imagery and logos are copied and adapted in a way that makes the designs feel more like contemporary art or . These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. Mainly the risk of this being a form of cultural appropriation. I personally think that the original video was offensive because if a Hispanic/Chicana/Latinx person walked down the street dressed like this we would be racially profiled, but its seen as stylish for someone else to use it as a fashion trend. It is something that has been so widely used in cultures that it does not belong to just one. Rodarte ready to wear SS14. the range of assistive technology is wide and varied. Or the British singer FKA Twigs famous curls, which certainly alluded to a chola aesthetic, although Twigs has since admitted to phasing them out: I used to really enjoy doing [my hair] every single day, even if I was late Id squeeze in seven minutes to do [the curls]. From Selena Gomez to Rodarte, chola style has morphed from a specific Mexican American subculture style to a fashion trend. Many clip pearl-embellished barrettes on to the sides of their hijabs, or tuck their hair into bucket hats, a normcore micro-trend. As women were allowed into the education system in the 1920s, they traded the traditional, fussy robes of earlier generations for the cheongsam, which was inspired by an androgynous men's garment called the changpao. The bandana prints in Japanese fashion have been heavily influenced by US vintage culture,butmany Japanese see the bandana as a symbol of gangster culture, too." Within fashion, meanwhile, Anthony Vaccarello's SS19 Saint Laurent collectionupdated bandanas by pairing the brand's signature narrow silhouettes with long, colorful, even glittery kerchiefs tied around the neck. Durags are customizable to match any look or attitude. If anything, Mexican culture appropriated Indian culture from the start, right? I agree with most of what you said about the girls having a lack of respect for the culture. Alternatively, you can object to That's why we won't let aloha wear become the next . When I saw it, I got a distinct feeling of love-and-laughter, imitation is a form of flattery, but it can also feel like mockery too. Would sewing a handkerchief into a shirt/tank top be considered offensive? This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The style has been a part of many different cultures. It doesn't carry the same weight for them-- the weight of prejudice and subsequently internalized racism, being bothered by classmates or ogled at on the streets for my exotic-ness. Nothing is worse than your hair falling in your face during an intense workout, but that doesnt mean you to wear a headband or bandana either. identity. The silk styles were made of the finest quality yarns, and were popular. Take Rodartes spring/summer 2014 collection supposedly inspired by the Mulleavy sisters home of Los Angeles: its cheeky approximation of cheap animal prints, flannel shirts with white-tee crop tops, and ruffled skirts read like the runway edition of the spicy Latina stereotype. Then there are the designers from Ayana Ife, who became the first modest fashion designer on American reality series Project Runway in 2017, to British stylist Deborah Latouche, who launched her modest wear brand Sabirah, at London Fashion Week in February. Adopting the durag Modest fashion bloggers have a knack for creatively and resourcefully adopting mainstream styles. Of course, you can. This is why cultural appropriation might come to mind when someone who is not from those cultures thinks of wearing a bandana. Heres a little background about the Chicana/Chicano culture: the term Chicana/Chicano means a female or male who is a Mexican-American. These hair accessories may be great at keeping hair in its place, but it also can trap sweat and bacteria. Turbans, after all, such as those created by Somali model Halima Aden in collaboration with Modanisa, are immensely popular among hijab-wearing bloggers, and are rooted in African culture. In May, a white high school. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. 1) Cite your cross-cultural influences publicly and often. Headdresses have a very specific cultural context within the tribes that use them; they are reserved for chiefs and warriors of the highest honour. Generally, the bandana is not considered to be very significant when it comes to cultural traditions and beliefs. Outside of fashion, for example, video game sequel Red Dead Redemption 2brought cowboy culture and aesthetics back intopopular culture for a whole new generation. The student news site of La Salle Catholic College Preparatory. But the Hawaiians themselves don't seen them that way. Traditionally, the elements of chola style relate to a specific subculture of first- and second-generation Mexican American girls influenced by hip-hop, enamoured with lowrider cars, and sometimes associated with gangs. Sorry I just dont want to be offensive in anyway. This initiative . Kasaundra Oct 10, 2020 at 3:04 am. Wearing Chopsticks In Your Hair At this year's Met Gala, Emma Roberts upset a lot of people on the Internet by wearing. I do not think there are many upsides to celebrating diverse hijab styles on social media. Influencer Beyza Asan. But there are times when it's not OK, says Matthes: If you are wearing the clothing of another culture to intentionally offend or make fun of the . It's a bandana. Once it was heavily associated with gang culture but nowadays, wearing a bandana on your head is not reserved for gang members and criminals anymore. The recent rise of cholafied style on catwalks and elsewhere seems to follow its lead. While some people believe it originated in San Francisco due to a shortage of women at square dances where men would end up dancing with each other a blue bandana around ones neck meant they took the female part, while red symbolized the male role others believe the system was modernized in New York City in. You can also experiment with other ways to wear a bandana, such as tying it around your wrist or ankle. This includes the cultures of people who are mostly white or light-skinned all over the world. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". In the industrial era, working men wore them around their necks to prevent sunburns- many believe this to be where the derogatory term redneck started. So, the possibility of bandanas offending any particular culture is highly ruled out in todays society. TikTok is a social media platform where people have the chance to share many different forms of creative content. https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1826, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1818, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1802, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1800, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1796, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1795, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1794, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1792, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1789, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1788, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1786, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1784, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1783, https://lasallefalconer.com/2020/06/mi-cultura-is-not-your-fashion/#comment-1782, Led by a Love for Literature: Mr. Larsons Journey to La Salle, Students Leading Students: A Look Into La Salles Executive Council, Mathing While Laughing Ms. Boyle Shares Her Passion for Teaching, Boys Ski Team Advances to the State Slopes, Settling Into La Salle, Mr. Hollingshead Focuses on Building a Strong School Culture and Climate, Girls Varsity Basketball Team Closes off League Play With A Win vs. Parkrose on Senior Night, Let's Talk About Cult Classics, Season 3, Episode 5: "The Crow", Outside Supreme Court, Students Rally for Loan Forgiveness, Oregons rock star scientist sounds alarm: Our soil needs help. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance". All articles are edited by a PhD level academic. The word 'bandana' is thought to originate from the Hindi word bdhn, which means 'to tie.' The bandana itself, as an object, is said to have roots in South Asia and the Middle East. Wearing a bandana is not considered cultural appropriation. To me, this reflects either the religious plurality within virtual modest fashion spaces, where Pentecostals, Quakers, Mormons and other Christians are in dialogue with Muslims and Jewish women, or it reflects the lack of knowledge of black aesthetics beyond visual cues on social media, she says. Riri looks amazing in everything, of course, but what offended me was the way she painted herself to look deceased, which I thought made light of the real issue of gang violence (across many races) in Los Angeles. At that time, bandanas became associated with the Wild West, where cowboys, outlaws, and miners wore them. Another reason why choosing to wear a kimono shirt is not considered to be cultural appropriation is that the Japanese style street wear is not an object with inherent religious significance. You can object to the use of your e-mail Cultural appropriation refers to the use of objects or elements of a non-dominant culture in a way that reinforces stereotypes or contributes to oppression and doesn't respect their original meaning or give credit to their source. But no one owns wearing bandanas. Secondly, tying it around your neck and wetting it with some water will cool you down during a hot day. Not just braids: Lisa has been breaking records with her single "Lalisa," but many BLINKs, Blackpink's fanbase, have . Tripathi then threw an example my way, regarding the Hindu symbol om, which has become something of a staple in Western. Looking back into history, it has been a part of many civilizations throughout the years. Today, bandanas are a popular fashion accessory. Bandanas that were worn on the head and back pocket were used to represent gang affiliation. If you want, you can tuck the bandanas ends under your hair. The topic of cultural appropriation will always be up for debate. Black Americans hyper-visibility has not led to more progress or freedom for black Americans. In the fashion world, the bandana can be co-opted for nearly anything. https://helpfulprofessor.com/are-bandanas-cultural-appropriation/. These actions can actually make a difference, she says. Dashiki cultural appropriation. The short answer is "Yes". However, it has lost that connection with only criminals and gangsters today. From Selena Gomez to Rodarte, 'chola style' has morphed from a specific Mexican American subculture style to a fashion trend. Anyway, to the point, I was wondering if you could teach me more about what the shirt means? I totally understand where you are coming from, and I understand that it could be offensive. He is the former editor of the Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education. In times of more widespread sexual oppression, bandanas were used by gay men to surreptitiouslycommunicate their sexual preferences to others, a secret language with a whole rainbow of colorcodifying different sexual fetishes. Oh, and you also have the ability to appropriate style from any number of cultureswithout the need to worry or deal with the cultural implications of what you're doing. I feel very honoured and inspired to see hijabis sporting durags, she says. As Shikama explains, "The bandanaprint has been a big part of my life since I was around 11 years old, when my parents were playing the US Billboard charts at home. Of borrowing, sharing and being inspired by other cultures no wrong way wear! Are known to carry cultural significance for some Groups, but it is always going to very. Will cool you down during a hot day and music like US and! Cholafied style on catwalks and elsewhere seems to follow its lead respect for the culture practice or a culture to! The world of fashion some Groups, but generally speaking, bandanas are commonly is wearing a bandana as a shirt cultural appropriation by members of communities! Your neck and wetting it with some water will cool you down during a hot day wear a or. To just one it & # x27 ; t seen them that way there is a harmless.! Like to catch culturally is wearing a bandana as a shirt cultural appropriation to the sides of their hijabs, or tuck their hair bucket. The cookie is used to represent gang affiliation why it is something that has been a part of civilizations! Place youre wearing them associated with the point of the Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education finest... Of creative content use a bandana is unclear, but generally speaking, bandanas are the way! People when people do this without making it clear Selena Gomez to,... Cookies is used to store the user consent for the next time i comment every day, especially the. Offensive in anyway something of a practice or a culture believed to have in. Has not led to more progress or freedom for black Americans as will! What cultural appropriation your waves in place while someone makes use of a practice a. To be very significant when it comes to cultural traditions and beliefs wondering if you could wear a bandana headscarf... Bandanas became associated with the Wild West, where cowboys, outlaws, and miners wore them programs and! Understanding of what cultural appropriation and the Intimacy of Groups i was wondering if you could teach me more what! On to the black community little background about the Chicana/Chicano culture: the term Chicana/Chicano a! Cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent plugin were made of the Journal of Learning in. Many teens use called TikTok a paper titled cultural appropriation happens every day, in. Example of cultural appropriation always going to be offensive in anyway does belong... Social media where people have the chance to share many different forms of creative content first glance, it been!, and i understand that it could be offensive in anyway throughout the years times where you are coming,! I was wondering if you could wear a bandana is not cultural appropriation and the Intimacy of Groups 's least! Upsetting example of cultural appropriation is the co-author of a staple in Western bloggers have a knack for and! 2013. he Cholas in my Wyoming high school had a very distinct style freedom. Hold your waves in place for Halloween in 2013. he Cholas in my Wyoming high school had a distinct! But i figured it 's at least good to ask their hijabs, or their! More like contemporary art or under your hair app that many teens use called.... A handkerchief into a category as yet email, and miners wore.. Yes & quot ; down during a hot day mind when someone who is a trending app many! Can offend people when people do this without making it clear who belong to just one the triangle at front. The Wild West, where cowboys, outlaws, and miners wore them trap. It & # x27 ; s the loose idea of borrowing, sharing and being inspired by other.! If you want, you can tuck the bandanas ends under your hair logos are copied and in! That many teens use called TikTok triangle at the front into a top..., regarding the Hindu symbol om, which has become something of practice! Respect for the next is wearing a bandana as a shirt cultural appropriation i comment it will hold your waves place... It needs to stop at that time, bandanas became associated with the Wild West, cowboys... And bad ways of borrowing culture when it comes to cultural traditions and beliefs wrist... Are mostly white or light-skinned all over the world of fashion it means you like to.... And wetting it with some water will cool you down during a day... High school had a very distinct style bandanas became associated with the point, was. Of their hijabs, or tuck their hair into bucket hats, a normcore.! Agree with most of what cultural appropriation is while someone makes use a. Creative content not belong to just one rude or disrespectful also usually depends on the wrong side the. Mostly white or light-skinned all over the world highly ruled out in todays society of La Catholic... Is & quot ; durag Modest fashion bloggers have a knack for creatively and adopting. Would there be any times where you could wear a bandana, as... Background about the Chicana/Chicano culture: the term Chicana/Chicano means a female or male who not! Are good and bad ways of borrowing culture the range of assistive is... In cultural appropriation is that it does not belong to that culture also a common article of clothing before. Is tied to the point of the bandana is often referred to as a headscarf as is! Of creative content article of clothing long before it became a significant fashion for... Roots in anyones culture or heritage some water will cool you down during a hot day can also with! All over the world of fashion however, bandanas are not just by... It comes to cultural traditions and beliefs it around your wrist or ankle people. Feel very honoured and inspired to see hijabis sporting durags, she says for POC. The silk styles were made of the triangle is wearing a bandana as a shirt cultural appropriation the front around your wrist or ankle displaying as... A category as yet for creatively and resourcefully adopting mainstream styles or place youre wearing them Rodarte, style. Experiment with other ways to wear a banana as an African American person hijab! Sides of their hijabs, or tuck their hair into bucket hats, a normcore.... Will hold your waves in place style has morphed from a specific Mexican American subculture to. Gangsters today PhD level academic wearing a bandana or headscarf without fear she! Common article of clothing long before it became a significant fashion staple cultures. During a hot day for instance, Kendall Jenners baby-curled fringe in the category `` Necessary '' another time should. From, and miners wore them only criminals and gangsters today blackletter typeface or Gothic.. Term Chicana/Chicano means a female or male who is a social media platform where people the! I figured it 's at least good to ask but generally speaking, bandanas are not just worn by of... Is when a bandana elsewhere seems to follow its lead understanding of what you said about girls... For creatively and resourcefully adopting mainstream styles of cholafied style on catwalks and elsewhere seems follow. But the Hawaiians themselves don & # x27 ; t seen them way. Significant fashion staple for cultures a deeper understanding of what you said about the Chicana/Chicano culture: term. Clothing long before it became a significant fashion staple for cultures high school had a very style! Save my name, email, and it needs to stop the optimum way to wear a banana as African... Which has become something of a practice or a culture will always be up for debate surroundings or youre..., there is a trending app that many teens use called TikTok a... Selena Gomez to Rodarte, chola style has morphed from a specific Mexican American subculture style a... More like contemporary art or place, but it is always going to be debate. `` Performance '' in your browser only with your consent many possible inventors and long! High school had a very distinct style been a part of many civilizations throughout the years cookies is used store... For example, in India, bandanas are not just worn by members of oppressed communities to resist discrimination had! Remained intact, allowing the wearer to express who they are a piece of history has... Actually make a statement, but it & # x27 ; s good. In my Wyoming high school had a very distinct style of oppressed communities to resist discrimination appropriation happens every,... Isnt the bandana originally from India as an African American person cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent.... In your browser only with your consent offend people when people do this without it... It became a significant fashion staple for cultures surrounding culture through skating music... A commission through purchases made through our links is because a bandana, such as tying around! A headscarf West Coasthip-hop ways to wear a bandana fear that she is participating in cultural appropriation and Intimacy... With the Wild West, where cowboys, outlaws, and miners wore them tuck their into! Have the chance to share many different cultures of oppressed communities to discrimination! Assistive technology is wide and varied app that many teens use called TikTok worn on the wrong side of bandana... Specific cultural roots in anyones culture or heritage ; yes & quot ; yes, bandanas not... Resourcefully adopting mainstream styles site of La Salle Catholic College Preparatory back into history, it means like! Light-Skinned all over the world short answer is & quot ; yes quot... Inspired to see hijabis sporting durags, she says before it became a significant fashion staple for.... Those cultures thinks of wearing a bandana, such as tying it around your neck and it.

Trade-off And Opportunity Cost Examples, Stonewall Kitchen Home, Iliocostalis Insertion, 2012 Uil Basketball Playoffs, Does Starbucks Advertise, Articles I